Policy

Medical review policy

Who checks our clinical content, what they check, how often it is re-reviewed and what medical review does not mean.

What medical review is

Medical review is an independent check of clinical content by a registered clinician before it is published and at regular intervals afterwards. The reviewer confirms that what we say about a condition, a procedure, its risks and its aftercare is accurate, balanced and consistent with current UK guidance. Reviewed pages show the reviewer's name, the date of review and the date the next review is due.

Medical review is not medical advice. A reviewed page is general information; it cannot take account of your history, your skin or the particular lesion you are concerned about. Only a clinician who has examined you can advise you.

Who our reviewers are

Every member of the reviewer panel must meet all of the following criteria, which we check when they join and again each year:

  • Full registration with the General Medical Council with a licence to practise, and no conditions, undertakings or warnings on their registration.
  • One of: entry on the GMC specialist register in dermatology or plastic surgery; or a general practitioner with an extended role in dermatology, holding a relevant postgraduate qualification and working in a dermatology service.
  • Current clinical practice involving the assessment or treatment of skin lesions within the last twelve months.
  • A signed declaration of interests, updated whenever their circumstances change, listing any clinic they work for, own or advise.

Reviewer profiles are published on the site with their registration number, so you can check them on the official register yourself. Reviewers are paid a fixed fee per review that does not depend on the content of the page, its traffic or any clinic mentioned on it.

What is reviewed

Content types and the review they receive
Content Medical review Who else checks it
Treatment guides and method pages Required before publication and every twelve months Health editor
Standalone guides and blog articles on clinical topics Required before publication and every twelve months Health editor
Frequently asked questions flagged as clinical Required; flagged questions cannot be published unreviewed Health editor
Safety and when to seek help Required before publication and every twelve months Health editor
Price guides and cost articles Not required unless they make clinical statements Data editor
Policy, trust and legal pages Not required Editor and, where relevant, legal adviser
Clinic-supplied text Not reviewed; moderated for advertising compliance Moderation team

What the reviewer checks

  • Clinical accuracy: descriptions of the condition, the procedure, anaesthesia, recovery and complications.
  • Balance: that benefits and limitations are presented together and that the page does not encourage removal where assessment is the appropriate first step.
  • Currency: that statements reflect current NHS, NICE and professional-body guidance, and that differences between UK nations are noted where they matter.
  • Safety wording: that the signs needing assessment are correct and that the safety notice appears where it should.
  • Suitability caveats: that the page makes clear who a procedure may not be suitable for and that suitability is decided at consultation.
  • Language: that no wording promises an outcome or minimises a risk.

The reviewer records their findings in writing. Content is not published until every finding has been resolved and the reviewer has signed off the final text. If the editor and reviewer disagree, the reviewer's view on a clinical point prevails.

Review cadence

Every reviewed page is re-reviewed at least every twelve months. The date of the next scheduled review is shown on the page. If a review is overdue, the page remains visible, because out-of-date general information is usually still safer than no information, but the page is labelled as due for review and is prioritised in the reviewer schedule.

What triggers an earlier re-review

  • A change to NHS, NICE or professional-body guidance on the condition or procedure.
  • New evidence, such as a systematic review, that could change what we say about effectiveness, risks or recovery.
  • A correction request or reader report raising a clinical point, whether or not it turns out to be right.
  • Regulatory action affecting a method, device or class of practitioner.
  • A substantial rewrite of the page by the editorial team.
  • The original reviewer leaving the panel or a change to their declared interests.

Conflicts of interest

Reviewers may work at clinics that are listed on the site; that is often what makes them qualified to review. To manage the conflict, a reviewer never reviews a page that mentions a clinic they work for, own or advise, and never reviews a treatment and location page for a city in which they practise. Their declared interests are shown on their profile. Reviewers have no role in verification, ranking, moderation or commercial decisions.

Tell us if anything on this page is wrong or out of date. Request a correction