Choosing a clinic

Dermatologist, plastic surgeon or GP: who should remove it?

All three carry out minor skin surgery in the UK, and for many lesions any of them would be a reasonable choice. What separates them is diagnosis, closure and cost.

Written by Sophie Hart Medically reviewed by Ms Helena Brandt
· 5 min read

This article is general information about types of clinician, not medical advice, and no clinic paid to be included in it.

  • choosing a clinic
  • dermatologist
  • plastic surgeon
  • GP

What each one brings

For a small benign lesion, all three are qualified to help, and the question is less about hierarchy than about which skill the job needs: working out what something is, closing the wound neatly, or dealing efficiently with something common. Knowing which you are paying for makes the quotes easier to read.

A consultant dermatologist is a doctor on the GMC specialist register for dermatology. Their strength is diagnosis: recognising what a lesion is, using dermoscopy, and knowing when something needs to be taken seriously. Most perform minor skin surgery routinely.

A consultant plastic surgeon is on the specialist register for plastic surgery. Their strength is reconstruction and closure: planning an incision so that it sits in a natural line, handling larger or awkward sites such as the nose, ear or eyelid, and managing difficult scars.

A GP with an extended role in dermatology is a general practitioner who has taken additional training and often runs minor surgery lists. For common, clearly benign lesions they are experienced, accessible and usually less expensive.

Matching the clinician to the lesion

A rough guide, not a rule
Situation Often suits Why
Uncertainty about what a lesion is Dermatologist Diagnosis and dermoscopy are the core of the specialty
Straightforward tags, warts, seborrhoeic keratoses GP with extended role, or nurse-led clinic Common, benign, quickly dealt with
Face, eyelid, ear or nose Plastic surgeon, or a dermatologist who does facial surgery Closure and cosmetic result need planning
Larger cyst or lipoma Plastic surgeon or general surgeon Deeper dissection and closure
A scar you are unhappy with Plastic surgeon Scar revision and non-surgical options

A lipoma or a deep cyst is a good example of the difference: the diagnosis is often straightforward, but removing it intact and closing the space left behind is surgical work. Titles are a starting point; experience with your particular lesion matters more. A clinician who removes ten of something a week is a reasonable choice whichever of the three they are.

Questions that separate them

  • How many of these do you do in a typical month?
  • What do you think this is, and what else could it be?
  • Will it be sent for laboratory examination, and will the report comment on the margins?
  • Where will the scar sit, which way will it run, and how long will it be?
  • If the result is unexpected, who refers me on and to where?

The answers tell you more than the specialty does. Our guide to questions to ask before private lesion removal has the full list, and you can confirm anyone's standing using how to check a doctor's GMC registration.

Cost and access

Fees generally rise from GP-led clinics through dermatology to plastic surgery, which reflects training, theatre requirements and the complexity of the work rather than the care you receive. Waiting times often run the other way, with GP-led minor surgery lists having shorter waits than a consultant clinic.

Paying more does not buy a better outcome on a simple lesion, and paying less is a poor saving on a difficult site. Match the clinician to the job, then compare prices within that group. Remember also that anything clinically concerning should go through your GP first, where assessment is free, and that NHS referral may take you to exactly the same consultant you would otherwise pay to see privately.

References

  1. The medical register General Medical Council. Accessed 9 September 2026.
  2. Good medical practice General Medical Council, January 2024. Accessed 9 September 2026.
  3. Cosmetic procedures NHS. Accessed 9 September 2026.

Who wrote and checked this article

This article is general information about types of clinician, not medical advice, and no clinic paid to be included in it.

The information on Skin Clinic Search is general guidance only and is not a substitute for advice from a registered clinician who has examined you. Whether a procedure is suitable can only be decided at a consultation.